CIHR Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes (INMD) – Strategic Plan 2021–2026
Table of Contents
- Message from CIHR-Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes Scientific Director, Dr. Norman Rosenblum
- 1. Introduction: Where are we now?
- 2. Where do we want to go?
- 3. How will we get there?
- 4. How will we know we have arrived?
- Appendix A: INMD Strategic Planning Process
- Appendix B: Performance Measurement Indicators for 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes
- Appendix C: INMD Institute Advisory Board
- Appendix D: INMD Staff
Message from CIHR-Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes Scientific Director, Dr. Norman Rosenblum
The world has changed dramatically since I began my term as INMD Scientific Director in January 2018 and engaged our Institute Advisory Board to generate a new INMD strategic plan. Clearly the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted every aspect of day-to-day life in Canada. The COVID-19 pandemic has served to highlight the critical importance of science and the health research enterprise in Canada and globally, and the need for adaptation and innovation within the Canadian health care system.
As the INMD Institute Advisory Board (IAB) was developing the new strategic plan, INMD focused on the development of a strategic research initiative to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the discovery of insulin to be marked in 2021. This research initiative, 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes, is an aspirational initiative that brings together international and national partners, and involves 10 of CIHR’s 13 Institutes working together to tackle the challenge of diabetes in its varied dimensions. We have also championed the development of CIHR’s new Health Research Training Platform Pilot, which will support integrated training and mentoring environments to position health research trainees and Early Career Researchers for career success.
The new INMD Strategic Plan aligns with CIHR’s new Strategic Plan 2021-2031 and priorities, and will contribute to CIHR meeting its overall objectives in key areas such as health equity, capacity development, supporting Indigenous Peoples’ health, interdisciplinary research, and team science. It will also support emerging science policy issues identified in CIHR’s Strategic Plan, such as inclusive concepts of research excellence, promotion of open science and inclusion of equity, diversity and inclusion.
This plan builds on past INMD successes, and will engage partners, create new opportunities for the research community, and most importantly, contribute towards improving the health of Canadians. Our vision is to ‘catalyze world-leading research that promotes optimal and equitable nutrition and metabolic health outcomes for Canadians’. This vision will drive an ambitious strategic plan that spans discovery, therapeutics, and translation with a particular focus on heterogeneity, health equity, and capacity within our research community.
To achieve this vision, INMD will bring together stakeholders to identify shared objectives and co-create meaningful and effective initiatives and maximize opportunities for the mobilization of knowledge. I look forward to working with INMD partners, both national and international, to implement our new INMD Strategic Plan in the coming years.
Yours in good health!
Norm Rosenblum, MD, FRCPC, FCAHS
Scientific Director
CIHR – Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes
1. Introduction: Where are we now?
About CIHR
The Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) is Canada's federal funding agency for health research. CIHR is comprised of 13 virtual Institutes that collectively deliver on CIHR’s mandate: to excel, according to internationally accepted standards of scientific excellence, in the creation of new knowledge and its translation into improved health for Canadians, more effective health services and products and a strengthened Canadian health care system.
CIHR is entering into a new period in its development. The CIHR Strategic Plan 2021–2031 outlines ambitious new priorities designed to enhance knowledge creation, knowledge mobilization, health equity and capacity building. CIHR will move as one part of Canada’s broad health research ecosystem, to achieve change that is both transformational and sustainable.
About CIHR Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes (CIHR-INMD)
As one of CIHR’s 13 Institutes, INMD engages the research community, including researchers, health professionals, voluntary health organizations, provincial health organizations, international research funders, industry and patient groups, and encourages interdisciplinary, integrative health research along the spectrum of basic discovery, clinical research, health services and population health and policy.
INMD was the subject of an in-depth evaluation in 2017, and was found to be successfully addressing an “overwhelmingly challenging” mandate. The evaluation noted that the impact of many diseases within INMD’s mandate falls disproportionately on certain populations. The evaluation further highlighted the need to increasingly address the particular disadvantage of Indigenous Peoples of Canada. The panel concluded that the Institute was well positioned to look forward and address Canada’s major challenges in nutrition and metabolic health.
“The evaluation found that the relevance of the mandate has been growing more important with the increasing levels of obesity and burden of chronic disease, largely diabetes. The Institute’s mandate covers important areas in the context of health of Canadians: nutrition, metabolism and diabetes all contribute significantly to general health and chronic conditions across the lifespan; diabetes, is a huge burden on the health care system in Canada and worldwide. INMD strives diligently to support the research community in the areas of priority, and this is reportedly valued by stakeholders, particularly by non-profit organizations and the public sector.”
Snapshot of Major Disease Burden in the INMD Mandate*
Diabetes
Prevalence:
- In 2020, an estimated 3.8 million Canadians were living with diabetes (including both type 1 and type 2 diabetes) (1).
- Certain populations are at higher risk of developing type 2 diabetes, including those of African, Arab, Asian, Hispanic, Indigenous, or South Asian descent (1).
- In 2018, diabetes mellitus was the 7th leading cause of death in Canada (2).
Health impact:
- Increased risk of diabetes complications including cardiovascular disease, vision loss, kidney failure, nerve damage, limb amputations.
- Approximately 38% of patients who started renal replacement therapy had diabetes as the main cause of their kidney failure (3).
Estimated Cost:
- Direct costs to healthcare were estimated at 3.8 billion per year, with significant out of pocket costs to patients (1).
- An Ontario study from 2004 to 2012 using a validated, population-based administrative diabetes registry found that over the 8 years of follow-up, incident diabetes was associated with more than double (~$10,000) in excess healthcare costs compared to non-diabetes controls (4).
Obesity
Prevalence:
- In 2018, an estimated 63% of Canadian adults (5) and 30% of children were overweight or obese (6).
- Overweight/obesity is 1.5 times more prevalent among Indigenous adults living off-reserve (7).
- Globally, high BMI ranked 4th among risk factors for mortality in 2017, primarily due to the effect of high BMI on cardiovascular disease. BMI prevalence continues to have one of the highest rates of increase over time (8).
Health impact:
- Increased risk of type 2 diabetes, asthma, cardiovascular disease, gallbladder disease, osteoarthritis, chronic back pain, and several types of cancer (9).
- Complications of obesity include not only physical health problems but also psychological concerns (e.g., low self-esteem) and negative attitudes and stereotypes about those who are obese have been linked to social and employment discrimination (9).
Estimated Cost:
- In 2008 the annual economic burden of obesity in Canada was estimated to be $4.6 B (9).
Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease (NAFLD) and Non-Alcoholic Steatohepatitis (NASH)
Prevalence:
- It is estimated that NAFLD, a major cause of chronic liver disease, affects about 20% of the Canadian population and almost 3% of children (10).
- It is estimated that 4% of Canadians have NASH (most severe form) (11).
Health impact:
- NASH is associated with ongoing liver damage and can lead to cirrhosis of the liver, liver cancer, and the need for a liver transplant (12).
Estimated Cost:
- It is estimated that lifetime direct costs of all adult NASH patients in the US in 2017 will be $222.6 billion and the cost of the advanced NASH population will be $95.4 billion USD (13).
- A study of adults in 5 European countries based on patient-reported outcomes found that patients with NASH reported worse quality of life and more health care resource use, including more visits to healthcare professionals and Emergency Rooms and more hospitalizations, compared to the general population and a matched cohort of adults with type 2 diabetes (14).
Nutrition & Food Insecurity
Prevalence:
- In 2017-18, 1 in 8 Canadian households were found to be food insecure (15), and based on 2014 data, 46.8% of households in Nunavut experience household food insecurity (16).
Health Impact:
- In 2017, one in five deaths globally, equivalent to 11 million deaths, were estimated to be associated with poor diet, and diet contributes to a range of chronic diseases with cardiovascular disease, cancers and type 2 diabetes being the leading causes of diet-related death (17).
- Food insecurity is associated with higher mortality rates and these higher rates are especially pronounced for the most severe food insecure (18).
Estimated Cost:
- Not meeting Canadian food recommendations was responsible for an estimated $13.8 billion/year (direct health care: CAD$5.1 billion, indirect: CAD$8.7 billion), based on 2014 costs (19).
Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD)
Prevalence:
- Between 2007-2009, an estimated 12.5% of Canadian adults were living with CKD in Canada (20), a condition for which there is no cure.
- Globally CKD ranks as the 12th leading cause of death out of 133 conditions and the prevalence of CKD reported in the Global Burden of Disease 2017 was 9·1% [95% Uncertainty Interval and 8·5 to 9·8]) (21).
- In 2018, kidney disease was the 10th leading cause of death in Canada (22).
Health impact:
- Diabetes and hypertension are key risk factors for CKD and increase treatment burden and decrease quality of life for people living with CKD.
- CKD is associated with very high risk of Coronary Artery Disease (CAD). CAD management is complicated in CKD patients, due to comorbid conditions and potential side effects during interventions (23).
Cost:
- In 2014, hemodialysis cost an estimated $56,000-107,000 per patient per year of treatment (24).
- End-stage renal disease cost the Canadian health-care system an estimated $1.8 billion in the year (25).
Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD)
Prevalence:
- Affects 0.7% of Canadians, and is expected to increase to nearly 1% by 2030 (26).
- Canada has among the highest rates of childhood-onset IBD in the world (27).
Health impact (28):
- Severe impact on quality of life due to abdominal pain, severe diarrhea, rectal bleeding, malnutrition and weight loss.
- Increased risk of osteoporosis, liver and eye inflammation, blood clots, arthritis, colorectal cancer, mental illness.
Cost:
- Economic costs estimated at $2.6 billion in Canada in 2018. Direct medical costs are approximately $1.28 billion, primarily prescription drugs and hospitalizations (29).
* The diseases and conditions featured here are the most prevalent among a host of disease states and conditions within the INMD mandate. Information presented is a limited snapshot based on the most recent nationally representative data, where available.
2. Where do we want to go?
The strategic priorities for 2021-26 were developed by the INMD Institute Advisory Board after consultation with researchers, and governmental and voluntary health organization partners recognizing the urgency and heavy burden of diseases and conditions in the INMD mandate (see Snapshot).
The INMD Strategic Plan for 2021-26 will catalyze world-leading research that promotes optimal and equitable nutrition and metabolic outcomes for Canadians.
Throughout this document, readers will note references to optimizing nutrition and metabolic health as a way to refer to supporting health and preventing or treating diseases within the INMD mandate. The term nutrition and metabolic health recognizes the inter-relationship of the processes involved in ingesting food and dietary components of appropriate quality and quantity, their absorption, metabolism, and excretion. These processes are needed for growth and development, health maintenance, tissue repair, and for the prevention and treatment of diseases that involve kidney, liver, endocrine and digestive systems.
INMD’s new strategic priorities will:
- forge a health research agenda and support capacity building across disciplines, sectors, and regions,
- embrace scientific opportunity and reflect the emerging health needs of Canadians and information needs of health policy decision-makers, and
- facilitate partnerships and accelerate the transfer of new knowledge into benefits for Canadians.
To achieve this expansive vision, INMD will work with stakeholders, including decision-makers and other knowledge users, to make critical investments and catalyze activities that will lead to a better understanding of the basis of human health and disease. These investments and activities will create opportunities for integrated knowledge translation and knowledge mobilization and will accelerate the translation of new knowledge into improved diagnostics, preventative policy and therapeutic interventions for diseases in the INMD mandate area.
CIHR has made a strong commitment to strengthening Indigenous health research in Canada. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada: Calls to Action (30) recognizes the legacy of residential schools and more broadly, the legacy of colonialism, on the health of Indigenous Peoples, the burden of chronic disease, and gaps in health outcomes between Indigneous and non-Indigenous communities. INMD’s new strategic priorities will include investment in research that supports the priorities of Indigenous communities and contributes to CIHR’s overall efforts in reducing health inequities.
The INMD Strategic Plan for 2021-2026 will build upon and leverage previous INMD investments and successes, including initiatives in Food and Health; Environments; Genes and Chronic Disease; and Obesity and Healthy Body Weight: Seeking Solutions, as well as key CIHR Initiatives such as Personalized Medicine and the SPOR Networks in Chronic Disease. With this solid foundation, INMD aims to challenge the upward trajectory to reduce the prevalence and impact of nutritional and metabolic diseases, and increase equitable health outcomes in Canada.
INMD Vision
Catalyzing world-leading research that promotes optimal and equitable nutrition and metabolic health outcomes for Canadians.
Strategic Priorities
INMD will contribute to improving the health and quality of life of Canadians by preventing and reversing the growing burden of INMD-related conditions (i.e., endocrine, liver, digestive, kidney and metabolic disorders); INMD will support research, knowledge mobilization and capacity building to:
- Accelerate Discovery: Identify and intervene in the physiological and molecular mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease.
- Harness Discovery and Diversity: Generate precision prevention, diagnosis and treatment strategies in nutrition and metabolic health.
- Pursue Health Equity: Develop preventive strategies through social, environmental and policy interventions that reduce nutritional and metabolic health inequities and improve community and population health.
- Support development of Canadian research capacity towards improved nutritional and metabolic health outcomes.
Strategic Priority 1
Accelerate Discovery: Identify and intervene in the physiological and molecular mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease
Specific objectives:
- Increase the generation and use of data from human studies to identify physiological and molecular mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease.
- Develop translational research models that recapitulate the mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease in humans.
- Increase the discovery, development and evaluation of therapeutic targets and interventions.
Numerous technologies have emerged in recent years that have created unprecedented opportunities to understand the biological basis of health and disease. However, the process of translating fundamental discoveries in animal models or tissues to the clinic and population health outcomes is long and expensive. Moreover, validation of pathways and targets in humans is often considered late in the discovery process. To speed the translation of discoveries along the continuum from discovery to health outcomes, INMD will support research that draws upon data from human studies to identify the physiological and molecular mechanisms of health and disease, research that integrates translational and discovery research, and research to assess potential therapeutic targets and interventions for further development.
This strategic priority will build on and expand existing Canadian research strengths in nutrition and metabolic health across the health research continuum with a focus on transcending the translational inertia that lies between basic science and clinical application. Support for interdisciplinary research will harness Canadian capacity for team science, to accelerate the generation of scientific knowledge and the identification and development of therapeutic targets, biomarkers and interventions.
Examples of Current Initiatives that Align with Strategic Priority 1
- Programmatic Grants in Environments, Genes and Chronic Disease.
- Canadian Microbiome Initiative 2: A Focus on Function and Translation.
- 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes.
- Netherlands-Canada Type 2 Diabetes Research Consortium.
- Team Grants in Diabetes Mechanisms and Translational Solutions.
Potential Actions for Strategic Priority 1
- Support research on physiological and molecular pathways involved in human nutrition and metabolism.
- Support translational research to identify and validate pre-clinical targets prioritizing research to identify physiological/ pathophysiological mechanisms in humans, with consideration of disease heterogeneity and dimensions of diversity.
- Support translational teams with the breadth and partnerships necessary to transform molecular discoveries into solutions for human health working with industry, professional and patient-based organizations.
- Develop approaches to validate pre-clinical targets in human biological materials.
- Support clinical research to assess the most promising therapeutic targets and interventions.
Strategic Priority 2
Harness Discovery and Diversity: Generate precision prevention, diagnosis and treatment strategies in nutrition and metabolic health
Specific objective:
- Develop resources and experimental approaches to better understand and address heterogeneity in disease susceptibility, progression and outcomes.
It is increasingly clear that one-size-fits-all approaches to prevention, diagnosis and treatment have limited effectiveness. Differences at the molecular, individual (e.g., sex and gender), and population level contribute to heterogeneity that significantly impacts the effectiveness of interventions, health equity, diagnostic tools and treatment approaches. Heterogeneity must be considered if we are to design improved approaches to prevention, diagnosis and treatment.
Numerous Canadian technological and data resources will facilitate research to address heterogeneity in nutrition and metabolic health and disease. Enhancing interdisciplinary work will be vital to: (1) harmonize and/or augment existing resources, (2) develop new methodologies to help us understand how heterogeneity contributes to nutrition and metabolic health and disease, and (3) develop precision prevention, diagnostic and treatment approaches that can be translated to clinical and public health settings to result in improved health outcomes for all Canadians.
Examples of Current Initiatives that Align with Strategic Priority 2
- Health Challenges in Chronic Inflammation – Phase 2.
- Human Immunology Initiative.
- Personalized Health.
- 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes:
- UK-Canada Diabetes Research Team Grants.
- Teams Grants in Diabetes Mechanisms and Translational Solutions.
Potential Actions for Strategic Priority 2
- Support the development of shared resources (e.g. cohorts, biobanks), including harmonization, enrichment and the development of common technical standards.
- Develop experimental approaches to generate data on disease phenotypes and risk stratification; as well as indicators of disease susceptibility, progression, response to interventions and outcomes in heterogeneous populations.
Strategic Priority 3
Pursue Health Equity: Develop preventive strategies through social, environmental and policy interventions that reduce nutritional and metabolic health inequities and improve community and population health
Specific objective:
- Assess the impact of social, environmental, and policy factors, to develop and evaluate interventions to improve nutritional and metabolic health and improve health equity across communities and populations.
For many years there has been a recognition that factors beyond individual biological factors and access to health services are important determinants of health and disease. Social and environmental conditions together greatly influence the health of populations and inequities in health and disease burden. It is critical to understand social and environmental factors, including built environment, food security and other factors, that influence health and disease, and to understand how to intervene successfully to effect changes that impact on health. INMD will support innovative social, environmental and policy research that builds on existing knowledge to inform preventive strategies and interventions to improve health status at the individual, community and population levels in relation to nutrition and metabolic health and disease.
This strategic priority will build on existing large datasets and contribute to developing new datasets where needed, and catalyze and develop interdisciplinary and inter-sectoral collaborations to ensure the research questions and approaches are relevant to policy makers.
Examples of Current Initiatives that Align with Strategic Priority 3
- Pathways to Health Equity for Aboriginal Peoples.
- Food Security and Climate Change in the Canadian North.
- Healthy Cities Research Initiative - Implementation Science Team Grants.
- 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes – Team Grants in Diabetes Prevention and Treatment in Indigenous Communities: Resilience and Wellness.
Potential Actions for Strategic Priority 3
- Support transdisciplinary research that uses emerging/integrated approaches (e.g. big data, AI) and partnerships with policymakers, organizations and communities to create, implement and evaluate social, environmental and policy interventions to improve nutritional and metabolic health.
- Support integration of shared data platforms and research by creating innovative linkages among existing datasets.
- Support Indigenous-led community driven research, leadership and partnerships that address social, environmental and policy factors in health outcomes and inequities using a resilience and wellness approach.
Strategic Priority 4
Support development of Canadian research capacity towards improved nutritional and metabolic health outcomes
Specific objectives:
- Support the development and sustainability of a community of outstanding researchers relevant to the INMD mandate.
- Support the principles of equity, diversity and inclusion in all INMD training and capacity-building initiatives.
- Work together with Indigenous communities to build capacity to lead and participate as researchers and partners.
Capacity building is about so much more than individual research training. INMD’s Strategic Plan for 2021 – 2026 supports programmatic approaches to build research capacity that will assist researchers in gaining the skills and experience that will create the research leaders of tomorrow. INMD recognizes the need to integrate the principles of equity, diversity and inclusion. In addition, INMD will work together with Indigenous communities, the CIHR Institute of Indigenous Peoples’ Health (IIPH), and CIHR’s Indigenous health research unit to build capacity to lead and participate as researchers and partners.
Examples of Current Initiatives that Align with Strategic Priority 4
- Health Research Training Platform Pilot.
- Network Environments in Indigenous Health Research.
- INMD Early Career Investigator Meetings.
- Sex and Gender Science Chair in Diabetes.
- Strategy for Patient-Oriented Research (SPOR).
Potential Actions for Strategic Priority 4
- Support targeted capacity building initiatives, such as training programs, to address needs for researchers at multiple career stages with specific expertise and experience.
- Support and facilitate the creation of transdisciplinary research including relevant partnerships with community, patient, government, healthcare, charity and industry.
- Help INMD-supported teams learn and share team science best-practices (e.g. team building/ maintenance, shared leadership, transdisciplinary collaboration, effective partnering).
- Through INMD investments and activities, address barriers and provide support for:
- Equitable and inclusive access to funding opportunities and participation in the research system.
- Data and analyses for decision-making informed by equity, diversity and inclusion.
- Capacity building in the INMD mandate within Indigenous communities consistent with the strategies outlined in A Vision for a Healthier Future, CIHR’s Strategic Plan 2021-2031 and the priorities of the CIHR Institute of Indigenous Peoples’ Health (IIPH).
3. How will we get there?
INMD will contribute to improving the health and quality of life of Canadians by preventing and reversing the growing burden of INMD-related conditions (i.e., endocrine, liver, digestive, kidney, nutritional and metabolic disorders). From 2021-26, INMD commits to playing a leading role as a convenor, thought-leader, and partner engaged with our investigator and clinical communities, patients, knowledge users, health charities, and policy-makers to support research, knowledge mobilization and capacity building aimed at addressing the following strategic priorities:
Specific Objectives | Emerging and Potential Actions | Short-term Indicators | Long-term Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
i. Increase the generation and use of data from human studies to identify physiological and molecular mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease |
Support research on physiological and molecular pathways that regulate human nutrition and metabolism:
|
INMD-supported researchers:
|
|
ii. Develop translational research models that recapitulate the mechanisms of nutritional and metabolic health and disease in humans |
Support translational research to identify physiological/ pathophysiological mechanisms in humans:
|
INMD-supported researchers:
|
|
iii. Increase the discovery, development and evaluation of therapeutic targets and interventions |
|
INMD-supported researchers:
|
|
Specific Objectives | Emerging and Potential Actions | Short-term Indicators | Long-term Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
i. Develop resources and experimental approaches to better understand and address heterogeneity in disease susceptibility, progression and outcomes |
Support the development of shared resources (e.g. cohorts, biobanks), including harmonization, enrichment and the development and implementation of common technical and ethical standards, as appropriate. Develop experimental approaches to generate data on:
|
|
|
Specific Objectives | Emerging and Potential Actions | Short-term Indicators | Long-term Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
i. Assess the impact of social, environmental, and policy factors, to develop and evaluate interventions to improve nutritional and metabolic health and reduce inequities across communities and populations |
Support transdisciplinary research that uses emerging/integrated approaches (e.g. big data, AI) and partnerships with policymakers, organizations and communities to create, implement and evaluate social, environmental and policy interventions to improve nutritional and metabolic health Support integration of shared data platforms and research by creating innovative linkages among existing and novel datasets (e.g. geo-spatial, environmental, nutritional, behavioural, health, genomics, and biomarker datasets) Support Indigenous-led community driven research, leadership and partnerships that address social, environmental and policy factors in health outcomes and inequities based on a resilience and wellness approach |
INMD-supported transdisciplinary teams and partnerships with diverse members, leaders and partners, including Indigenous community leadership, engagement and knowledge base
|
|
Specific Objectives | Emerging and Potential Actions | Short-term Indicators | Long-term Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
i. Support the development and sustainability of a community of outstanding researchers relevant to the INMD mandate |
Support and facilitate:
|
INMD-supported researchers, teams, partnerships and networks:
|
|
ii. Support the principles of equity, diversity and inclusion in all INMD training and capacity-building initaitives |
Through INMD investments and activities, address barriers, and provide support for:
|
INMD-supported researchers, teams, partnerships and networks:
|
|
iii. Work together with Indigenous communities to build capacity to lead and participate as researchers and partners |
Through INMD investments and activities, address barriers, and provide support for capacity building in the INMD mandate within Indigenous communities consistent with the priorities of the CIHR Institute of Indigenous Peoples’ Health (IIPH) |
INMD-supported researchers, teams, partnerships and networks demonstrate increased capacity in the INMD mandate within Indigenous communities |
|
4. How will we know we have arrived?
INMD is committed to evaluating the outputs and outcomes of the research activities undertaken during the time period covered by this INMD strategic plan. CIHR has developed a robust approach to monitoring and evaluation, which includes a plan for regular assessment of institute performance, similar to the evaluation of INMD undertaken in 2017. Assessing scientific impact is inherently complex and multi-dimensional and for this reason, a multi-dimensional approach needs to be used that incorporates both qualitative and quantitative measures, including bibliometrics, surveys, and data analyses.
In the absence of implementation details, yet to be established for many of the new INMD strategic priorities described above, it is not possible to provide performance measurement indicators. In contrast, INMD has developed potential indicators of performance measurement for the INMD-led, multi-institute, multi-component initiative, 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes, which is currently being implemented. See Appendix B for details.
Appendix A: INMD Strategic Planning Process
INMD developed this strategic plan through an iterative development process with the INMD Institute Advisory Board (IAB) to select and validate priorities using a consensus approach and based on input received from the INMD research community and partners.
The development of the new INMD Strategic Plan began with the appointment of Dr. Norman Rosenblum in January 2018, and an INMD Institute Advisory Board meeting held in Toronto in April 2018. At this first IAB meeting, IAB members were asked to review the INMD Institute Evaluation that was completed in May 2017. The Report of the INMD Evaluation Panel is available on the INMD web site and was circulated in the meeting materials sent in advance of the IAB meeting, along with the previous version of the INMD Strategic Plan. IAB members were also asked to consider materials pertaining to the context of the development of the INMD Strategic Plan, and various approaches to Strategic Planning. At this point, the IAB divided into two working groups: Group 1 was tasked with stakeholder outreach, which involved speaking with key stakeholder groups, health charities, community/society members, to request their strategic plans and priorities and to advise INMD staff on the development of a stakeholder survey and Group 2 was tasked with looking at INMD-relevant funding data, which included the identification of data gaps.
In May 2018, INMD sent a survey to its partners (health charities, community/society members) to seek input into the development of the new INMD strategic plan. These stakeholders were requested to complete the survey on behalf of their organization and to seek input from their constituency (e.g., Scientific Advisory Committee, Board of Directors, membership including patients/patient partners), so that the response reflected the views of their respective organization. Responses from 11 organizations were received by September 2018. This input was considered and discussed by the INMD IAB, along with the funding data, at the November 2018 meeting held in Winnipeg. At this meeting, the IAB recommended that INMD survey researchers directly and IAB members offered to screen through the responses for themes and new ideas. This survey was promoted through the INMD newsletter in December 2018, with responses due by end of January 2019. A total of 68 responses were received. In addition, it was suggested that INMD engage with relevant Government stakeholders to seek input including Health Canada, Public Health Agency of Canada, and Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, as well as provincial health research funders through the National Alliance of Provincial Health Research Organizatios (NAPHRO). The INMD Scientific Director met with representatives from all of these organizations to seek input.
In February 2019, the INMD met in Toronto for a one-day special meeting focused on the development of the Strategic Plan. At this meeting, the IAB discussed the core values or principles for consideration in the context of the new INMD Strategic Plan. These principles included:
- Inclusivity, recognizing the broad mandate of INMD.
- Integration of systems and areas of the INMD mandate.
- Equity, diversity and inclusion, given the burden of diseases in INMD mandate areas is not equally distributed in the Canadian population.
- Support the priorities of Indigenous communities and contribute to CIHR’s overall efforts in reducing health inequities in First Nations, Metis and Inuit communities.
- Capacity-building as a fundamental element of the Strategic Plan.
- Striving for the impact of strategic research and related activities contributes to CIHR’s overall mandate of improving the health of Canadians and the Canadian health care systems.
At this February meeting, the IAB broke into small groups to try to identify common themes that emerged from the stakeholder input collected. A number of groupings or themes began to emerge, with a focus on nutrition and metabolism, and prevention, reversal and reduction of chronic diseases in the INMD mandate by prioritizing:
- Novel mechanisms and approaches to chronic disease progression and reversal.
- Innovative social, environmental and policy solutions to disease prevention and treatment.
- Heterogeneity – mechanisms, biomarkers, moving towards precision-based approaches to address heterogeneity in disease susceptibility, treatment and outcomes (across pillars).
These themes required further development given the identification of divergent topics and resources that needed to be considered in formulating a final set of priorities. Accordingly, in October 2019, the IAB met in Edmonton to further develop these themes and corresponding objectives and performance measures. These discussions were facilated by an independent external facilitator, Michelle Campbell, who helped prompt the IAB to work through this process, and assisted INMD in producing an initial draft of the INMD Strategic Plan after the meeting.
Unfortunately the INMD IAB was forced to cancel face-to-face meetings during 2020 as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic; however, work continued on the draft version of the INMD Strategic Plan by INMD staff, and the IAB were asked to provide input and comments on these drafts. In November 2020, the INMD IAB met virtually and approved the final draft version of the INMD Strategic Plan prior to INMD staff submitting it for approval within CIHR.
Appendix B: Performance Measurement Indicators for 100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes
100 Years of Insulin: Accelerating Canadian Discoveries to Defeat Diabetes
Goal: to develop new preventive and therapeutic paradigms that reverse the upward trajectory of diabetes prevalence and associated morbidities, and reduce the impact of diabetes on individuals, families and communities.
The objectives of this initiative are:
- To elucidate previously undefined mechanisms that control the onset and progression of all types of diabetes mellitus and related complications.
- To develop translational solutions aimed at prevention, treatment, and delivery of care for people living with diabetes to:
- Accelerate stem cell research aimed at physiological insulin replacement for people with type 1 diabetes.
- Develop new therapeutic strategies aimed at metabolic reset and reversal of type 2 diabetes.
- Develop and implement effective models of care delivery aimed at improving diabetes care and patient outcomes.
- To define and integrate models of resilience and wellness into diabetes prevention and treatment approaches among First Nations, Inuit and Métis Peoples that are Indigenous-led and community-driven to reverse the upward trajectory of diabetes in these communities.
Category | Description | Potential indicators |
---|---|---|
Advancing knowledge |
discoveries/breakthroughs, contributions to the scientific literature (grey or peer-reviewed) and may include measures of research quality, activity, outreach and structure |
|
Building capacity |
the development and enhancement of research skills in individuals and teams, additional research-activity funding (e.g., funding partnerships) as well as the development/enhancement of platforms |
|
Informing decision-making |
includes the impacts of health research in the areas of health related decision-making (i.e., science/research, general public, clinical and managerial decision-making, practice and policy and health products decision making) |
|
Health and Health System impacts |
advances in the prevention, diagnosis, treatment and palliation as well as changing health status and determinants of health. |
|
Broad economic and social impacts |
commercialization of research discoveries, human capital gains, health benefits (specific costs of implementing research findings in the broad health system), well-being and social benefit indicators |
|
Appendix C: INMD Institute Advisory Board
Christopher Kennedy (Chair)
Senior Scientist, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute & Kidney Research Centre
Professor, Departments of Medicine & Cellular and Molecular Medicine
University of Ottawa
Catherine Field (Vice Chair)
Professor, Department of Agricultural, Food and Nutritional Science
University of Alberta
Stephanie Atkinson (Former Chair)
Professor, Department of Pediatrics
McMaster University
Gillian Booth
Associate Professor, Department of Medicine
University of Toronto
Scientist, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute
St. Michael's Hospital
Sukhinder Cheema
Professor, Department of Biochemistry
Cross-appointed, Biomedical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine
Memorial University of Newfoundland
Elisabeth Fowler
Chief Executive Officer
Canadian Ophthalmological Society
Julie Ho
Associate Professor, Departments of Internal Medicine & Immunology
University of Manitoba
Stephen James
Director, Division of Digestive Diseases and Nutrition
National Institutes of Health
National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases
Tony Lam
Senior Scientist, Toronto General Hospital Research Institute
Professor, Department of Physiology
University of Toronto
Wally MacNaughton
Professor and Head, Department of Physiology and Pharmacology
University of Calgary
Douglas Manuel
Senior Scientist, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute
Senior Medical Advisor, Statistics Canada
Professor, Department of Family Medicine and School of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Ottawa
Core Senior Scientist, Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences
Marc Prentki
Professor, Department of Nutrition
Université de Montréal
Director, Montreal Diabetes Research Center
Erica Samms-Hurley
Nurse Educator, Western Regional School of Nursing
Memorial University of Newfoundland
George Tolomiczenko
Executive Director
Merkin Institute for Translational Research
California Institute of Technology
Bruce Verchere
Investigator, BC Children's Hospital
Professor, Departments of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine & Surgery
University of British Columbia
Appendix D: Institute of Nutrition, Metabolism and Diabetes Staff
Norman Rosenblum MD, FRCPC, FCAHS
Scientific Director
Mary-Jo Makarchuk MSc, MHSc, RD
Assistant Director
Keeley Rose MSc, PhD*
Project Manager
Christine Dhara BSc, PMP
Business Officer
Hasnain Saherawala BSc
Project Analyst
INMD would like to thank Michelle Campbell for her work on this strategic plan.
References
- Diabetes in Canada: Backgrounder. Ottawa: Diabetes Canada; 2020.
- Statistics Canada. Table 13-10-0394-01 Leading causes of death, total population, by age group.
- Canadian Institute for Health Information. Annual Statistics on Organ Replacement in Canada: Dialysis, Transplantation and Donation, 2009 to 2018. Ottawa, ON: CIHI; 2019.
- Rosella LC, et al. Impact of diabetes on healthcare costs in a population-based cohort: a cost analysis. 2016 Diabet. Med. 33, 395–403. DOI: 10.1111/dme.12858.
- Statistics Canada. Overweight and Obese Adults, 2018. Health Fact Sheet (Release Date June 25, 2019). Catalogue No. 82-625-X.ISSN 1920-9118.
- Public Health Agency of Canada. Tackling obesity in Canada: Childhood obesity and excess weight rates in Canada. 2017. https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/publications/healthy-living/obesity-excess-weight-rates-canadian-children.html
- Public Health Agency of Canada. Key Health Inequalities in Canada: A National Portrait. Ottawa: Public Health Agency of Canada; 2018.
- GBD 2017 Risk Factor Collaborators. Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 84 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks for 195 countries and territories, 1990–2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet 2018; 392: 1923-1994.
- Obesity in Canada: A joint report from the Public Health Agency of Canada and the Canadian Institute for Health Information: Health and economic implications. Ottawa, 2011.
- Canadian Liver Foundation. https://www.liver.ca/patients-caregivers/liver-diseases/fatty-liver-disease/
- Canadian Liver Foundation.
- Fazel Y et al. Epidemiology and natural history of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Metabolism - Clinical and Experimental 2016; 65 (8): 1017 – 1025.
- Younossi et al. Burden of Illness and Economic Model for Patients With Nonalcoholic Steatohepatitis in the United States. Hepatology, 2019: 69 (2): 564-572.
- Balp M-M et al. The burden of non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) among patients from Europe: A real-world patient-reported outcomes study. JHEP Reports 2019; vol. 1|154–161.
- Tarasuk V, Mitchell A. (2020) Household food insecurity in Canada, 2017-18. Toronto: Research to identify policy options to reduce food insecurity (PROOF).
- Fafard St-Germain A, Galloway T and Tarasuk V. (2019). Food insecurity in Nunavut following the introduction of Nutrition North Canada. CMAJ 191(20): E552-E558. DOI.
- GBD 2017 Diet Collaborators (2019) Health effects of dietary risks in 195 countries, 1990–2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet 2019; 393: 1958–72. https://doi.org/10.1016/ S0140-6736(19)30041-8.
- Gundersen C, Tarasuk V, Cheng J, de Oliveira C, Kurdyak P (2018) Food insecurity status and mortality among adults in Ontario, Canada. PLoS ONE 13(8): e0202642.
- Lieffers JRL, Ekwaru JP, Ohinmaa A, Veugelers PJ (2018) The economic burden of not meeting food recommendations in Canada: The cost of doing nothing. PLoS ONE 13(4): e0196333.
- Arora et al. Prevalence estimates of chronic kidney disease in Canada: results of a nationally representative survey. CMAJ. 2013; 185(9): E417–E423.
- GBD Chronic Kidney Disease Collaboration. Global, regional, and national burden of chronic kidney disease, 1990–2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet 2020; 395: 709–33.
- Statistics Canada. Table 13-10-0394-01 Leading causes of death, total population, by age group.
- Sarnak MJ, Amann K, Bangalore S, et al. Chronic Kidney Disease and Coronary Artery Disease, 2019; JACC 74(14): 1823- 1838. DOI: 10.1016/j.jacc.2019.08.1017.
- Klarenbach SW, Tonelli M, Chui B, Manns BJ. Economic evaluation of dialysis therapies. Nature Reviews Nephrology. November 2014.
- Zelmer JL. The economic burden of end-stage renal disease in Canada. Kidney International (2007); 72, 1122–1129.
- The Impact of Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Canada 2018. Journal of the Canadian Association of Gastroenterology, 2(S1).
- Carroll Matthew W, et al. The Impact of Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Canada 2018: Children and Adolescents with IBD. Journal of the Canadian Association of Gastroenterology February 2019; Volume 2, Issue Supplement 1, Pages S49–S67.
- Crohn’s and Colitis Canada.
- Crohn’s and Colitis Canada. The Impact of Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Canada 2018.
- Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada: Calls to Action. Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, 2012. Retrieved May 19, 2020.
- Date modified: