RQA Checklist
Mock Review Toolkit – Project Grant Competition: Running the Simulation
For Facilitators: If the meeting is in-person, this resource is printed and distributed to participants during the meeting. If the meeting is virtual, send this resource as an attachment with the Confirmation of Committee Meeting email prior to the meeting. Please remove this instructional text before sending to participants.
The integrity of the peer review system relies on the ability of reviewers to exercise fair and rigorous judgement. The following checklist was developed as a practical tool to assist reviewers to apply the review quality criteria, which helps ensure consistent and fair reviews. Please refer to this checklist as you are writing your reviews.
Criterion | Interpretation |
---|---|
Appropriateness Review comments are fair, understandable, confidential and respectful. |
|
Robustness Review is thorough, complete and credible |
|
Utility Review provides feedback that addresses the needs of reviewers, applicants and funders. |
|
- Date modified: